Saturday, July 14, 2007

Take 20 Piece

This nearly killed me, but I have a video response piece on the Take 20 DVD that is about New Media writing.

It is about 14 minutes long--enjoy!

http://media.english.ttu.edu/graduate/irvin/Take20LLI.wmv

Saturday, July 7, 2007

Annotated Bibliography beginnings

I am not that far along with my annotated bibliography so far. I've mostly been researching and researching in the databases and on the web for any research studies I can find that investigate the role of what I call "rhetorical reflection" (in-task, writer-based, validity testing) in the writing process. I have only really found one, but I'm still searching and getting into past research done on metacognition and the writing process by Flower and Hayes and others.

So far I have my list of possible studies. I'm still adding to it--
http://www.accd.edu/sac/english/lirvin/TTech/5060/ResearchRhetReflect.pdf

I also have developed a table to chart out each research study reference:

Chart for Research Assessment

Title/Author

Research Question(s)

What are the focused questions for this research?

Research Approach

Quantitative, Qualitative, Mixed Methods

Knowledge Claims

(methodology)

Postpositivism—determination, reductionism, empirical observation and measurement, theory verification

Constructivism—understanding, multiple participant meanings, social and historical constraints, theory generation

Advocacy/Participatory—political, empowerment issue-oriented, collaborative, change-oriented

Pragmatism—consequences of actions, problem-centered, pluralistic, real-world practice oriented (6)

Strategies of Inquiry

Operating at a more applied level are strategies of inquiry that provide specific direction for procedures (or methods) in a research design. (13)

Methods

Specific methods performed following the general strategy of inquiry

Sample/Sampling

How did they choose/gather the sample? What is the size of the sample? What forms of rigor were applied to their sampling?

Data Analysis

How was the data interpreted? What forms of rigor were applied to their data analysis?

Results

What were the results of their research?

Assessment

Overall assessment of this research project?

So far I have only one source fit into this chart:

Title/Author

Anson, Chris. "Talking About Writing: A Classroom-Based Study of Students' Reflections on Their Drafts." Self-Assessment and Development in Writing: A Collaborative Inquiry. New Jersey: Hampton Press, 2000: 59-74.

Research Question(s)

How do writers represent their own writing process? How do they talk about their writing? Can we explore writer's reflections on their emergent texts to understand how writers develop expertise

Research Approach

Qualitative

Knowledge Claims

(methodology)

Constructivism

Strategies of Inquiry

Classroom-based research, purely descriptive, case study

Content analysis? Rhetorical analysis

Methods

Talk aloud protocol--"retrospective accounts" done in naturalistic setting (within context of class)

Sample/Sampling

Taped recorded narrative commentaries about the process of writing a first draft turned in with draft. Few strict guidelines put on focus of tapes (i.e. no direct prompts).

Does not specify number of sample—only says "classes."
Selected accounts used for data analysis based on whether they were the very best or very worst writers. No specific number of how many fit into this sample.

Data Analysis

Developed a coding analysis rubric based on two poles:
1) Halliday's functional approach to language
--Ideational (speaker's content)
--Interpersonal (audience)
--Textual (language)
2) Time-oriented dimension
--Retrospective (what he or she did during creation of text)

--Projective (focus on actions the writer says he or she intends to do)
--Temporal (occurs in the present moment)

Developed rubric with nine possible combinations from the two axes (functional/time-oriented)
e.g. : R/ID = Retrospective/Ideational

No evidence of use of inter-rater reliability done

Brings in theories of intellectual development from Perry's Model of Intellectual Development in his interpretation of data

Results

Stronger writers showed more control of their writing process; weaker students lack control, seldom comment projectively. There is an unmistakably "absolutist" quality in the metacommentaries of students who speak of their writing textually and in the past tense, and there is an unmistakably "evaluistic" quality in the talk of both successful novice writers and experienced writers as they shift among functions, retrospect and project, and embrace uncertainty in their own control of their work.

It appears that there is a strong relationship between proficiency and the blending/shifting of functions in scheme.

Concludes with how this metacommentary can enable him in his classroom practice to provide better feedback and direction to struggling writers.

Assessment

This article is focused directly on the type of "data" I am interested in and develops a VERY interesting tool for coding this data. He varies from me in that he transcribes verbal accounts and I use written accounts. This seems interesting to me and significant since I seem to base a fair amount of my thinking on the importance of the act of writing. His sampling seems problematic to me, but he is being descriptive, qualitative. Should he have used inter-rater reliability checks to assess the usefulness of his coding rubric? Since he is not counting tendencies, perhaps not.

I plan to create charts like this for ten to twenty research studies that I have. The problem is that few focus directly on what I want to study, so I have to interpellate to other instances of reflection that I could consider "rhetorical." I know that I am not far in this process, but that is where I am right now. More progress to come next week.

~L

Monday, July 2, 2007

What Should Be Taught?


What exactly should be taught in composition, in your opinion, how should it be taught, and what should you do in order to know if what was taught was learned?

These are the central questions behind each class of Freshman Composition that I teach, and what I write here will only be a sketch. Up front, I want to voice my strong belief that Freshman Composition should have writing as its "subject"--not literature, not making students better people, not social consciousness. Pardoxically, if writing is only considered as a "subject" (i.e. some definable content of knowledge), a writing class becomes too narrow and prescriptive because writing is predominantly an activity or as Aristotle and other classical rhetoricians called a "faculty"--not just a subject.

I want to open with two curious quotes that get to the heart of this question--what do/can we teach?

"...the degree to which any kind of knowledge or any given skill in writing is generalizable--that is, transferable from one context to another--will always be problematic, in fact, that beyond a few general principles, there may be little we can say about how novices develop the broad knowledge and skills it takes to write" (Smit 133)

Lee Ann Kastman Bruech also says, "I suggest that there is no identifiable post-process theory pedagogy that we can concretely apply to the writing classrooms" (98), and later advises teachers to "let go the curriculum."

Each of these authors seems to throw up their hands and say writing is too complex, so it is unteachable. As composition scholars like James Moffett and Linda Flower have demonstrated, "literacy" involves a whole lot more than just grammatical or even formal proficiency. Linda Flower in her book The Construction of Negotiated Meaning: A Social Cognitive Theory of Writing charts out this more complex view of literacy (that others like Smit and Bruech say is unteachable). She labels three parts to this literacy: literacy as identity, literacy as practice, and literacy as negotiation. The first literacy involves membership within a Discourse community. She goes on to describe literacy as practice as literate action: "literate action is a socially situated problem-solving process shaped not only by available language, practices, partners, and texts, but by the ways people interpret the rhetorical situation they find themselves in, the goals they set, and the strategies they control" (2). This literate action, she says, can mean the conventions of discourse, but also that it centrally involves the "making of meaning": "Literate actions emerge out of a constructive cognitive process that transforms knowledge in purposeful ways. And at critical moments, this constructive literate act may also become a process of negotiation in which individual readers and writers must juggle conflicting demands and chart a path among alternative goals, constraints, and possibilities" (2). Smit calls this kind of literacy "rhetorical maturity," and I would say my biggest goal in Fresh Comp is to develop this expanded view of literacy, this rhetorical maturity (123). Coming out of my own experience in Freshman Composition and my own development as a writer, I am keenly aware that I cannot get all my students to a high level of literacy and writing skill in Fresh Comp. Instead, I can develop the awareness and ingrain some of the habits of writing that they can use in the future to found their continued development as writers.

What I find curious about some post-process scholars is that they basically throw up their hands and say writing is so situated, so complex, so founded upon interpretation, that it is unteachable. Hah! What is a writing teacher supposed to do with that? Expressivist teachers had this view, advocating the notion that writing can't be taught but it can be learned and the best way to learn to write is by writing. I definitely come from expressivist roots, and this argument against prescriptive, explicit instruction in "rules" of writing certainly agrees with me, yet their is much guidance and support that we can do as teachers and there are skills and strategies we can try to impart. I can't recall which reading from my Contemp Rhetoric class this came from(I.A Richards I think), but I recall a discussion about the trivium (grammar, logic, rhetoric), and how you can see in the history of rhetoric how these three have been separated from each other. But this discussion talked about how these three interanimate and depend upon each other. I think I try to teach how all these three aspects of communication together (the technical features of the text used to communicate, the thinking behind what is said, and manner in which it is presented). It can be hard to do, especially if a student has problems in a particular area like comma splices.

Briefly, let me chart out the general trajectory of my composition class as I have done it (though I have not always done it this way).

I tend to follow Britton and Moffett's sequence of moving from narrative/descriptive writing to analytical writing. I start from students writing about their experience as the "text" to base their writing about to begin negotiating their interior views with the world (writing, then, founded upon exterior "texts"). Start IN; then move OUT and back IN. Fresh Comp I is a gradual movement from this interior to exterior. Along the way, I try to inculcate the ability to include specific illustrations or examples for general statements whether this be in descriptive writing or using stories to exemplify some idea. Later in Fresh Comp II, this principle of elaboration (or support or making specific) is the skill of using support from the text. I also begin in Fresh Comp I to teach them researching. If Fresh Comp I (for me) is about a writer gaining more control and proficiency with negotiating their own language (without too much interference from the outside as in excessive readings), Fresh Comp II is where I have students work more diligently with handling outside sources and views in their own writing. I attempt to push my students off center in their thinking by working on topics that have no clear cut answer (that is, move them beyond the stage of dualistic thinking stated by Perry). How will they form their belief with the understanding that it is not THE answer, but AN answer (that is hopefully well reasoned and well founded).

I'm more and more questioning my learning sequence in Fresh Comp, but it seems to have a logical movement that matches well with where Freshman are in their development. The problem with the sequence is that it serves academic writing predominantly, especially Fresh Comp II. I have become more and more enchanted with teaching rhetorical proficiency--not just academic writing proficiency. Those things are not necessarily the same thing. I'm wondering now if there may be a sequence in that academic proficiency is a necessary stepping stone to more higher level rhetorical proficiency. I don't know.

I think my video on Porfolios is a pretty good description of how I teach writing--at least in Freshman Comp I.



Saturday, June 23, 2007

Teaching and Theory

What are the core movements in the history of composition (as summarized by Berlin and Fulkerson), and which elements of each can you relate to in your own teaching philosophy?

For me, I am a tangle of all these approaches. I have an intellectual theory (sort of like a philosophy) that totally favors New Rhetoric with its social epistemic beliefs in how language works and how we learn to write, but as I look at my own practice I find that these categories (formalist, expressivist, mimetic , rhetorical or classicist, current-traditional, expressivist, epistemic) are played out in my practice more as the exception that the rule. I can't say I have a practice that is purely one or the other--so, in the eyes of Knoblauch and Brannon, Fulkerson, and Berlin I am guilty of "modal confusion." For Fulkerson, I am guilty of "mindlessness" and must have "[failed] to have a consistent value theory or fail[ed] to let that philosophy shape [my] pedagogy" (554).

Perhaps some of this modal confusion comes from the mixed way I began teaching. I'll try to describe the three different classes I initially taught and their very different approaches. I began at Palo Alto College in 1989 with one section of Freshman Composition II taught at Kelly Air Force Base. It was Lit/Comp. We read Hamlet and poetry and short stories and The Great Gatsby. I sort of lectured and led class discussion and my students wrote critical analyses of the literature--that is, the "critical essay." This is formalist, current-traditional teaching of literature as I had been taught in college. Exigesis. The most important thing was to find sufficient evidence IN THE TEXT for your thesis. Perhaps this was a bit mimetic too (I don't find Fulkerson's distinctions between formalist and mimetic to be clear since often formalist teach in mimetic ways). The next semester I was hired as a full-time temporary instructor with six sections of English 1301 (I was talked into an overload). Searching for help in how to teach this class, I luckily stumbled into Ellen Shull who used portfolios and a writing workshop model for her class. I followed her practice as closely as I could. I also found Beat Not the Poor Desk which provided me with the essay assignments for how I taught 1301 for many years. It was almost in the purest form an expressivist classroom. The topics were personal in nature and the "text" students read was their own lives and the writings of their peers. We might read a novel or two, but these were complementary texts for inspiration and even as models. Students worked on their "writing skills" as they sought "to say what they truly meant to say" in as full and powerful a way as they could. It was great.

The next Fall, though, I for the first time was given a Developmental English class. And my text was John Langan's College Writing Skills. In the preface to the textbook, Langan recounts an incident that shapes his approach to writing. He had gotten a paper back from a college professor with a poor grade and it had some cryptic notes on it that said "log." He visited his professor and asked what this "log" means. The professor replied, "Logic my young man. Logic" (or something like that). His essay had flaws in logic. Since it was my first time teaching, I swallowed Langan's textbook whole and followed it closely. He has clear instructions and good models, so it was easy. It also rang true to what I had considered to be "the essay" from my college and graduate school experience. Thesis--Primary Supports--Secondary Supports--Details. Freshman Comp. II essays were the same things, but on steroids (that is, with more textual support).

So I began (and continued) my college teaching using different approaches or philosophies to teaching with different classes. Developmental Writing and Fresh Comp II very formalist and Fresh Comp I very expressivist. As I moved into teaching in the computer classroom, I became more enamored with "social constructivism" and the "negotiation of meaning" and have always in these environments facilitated the sharing of text. Every piece of writing (except journals) is public. My philosophical center of gravity moved more toward the social epistemic, and thanks to my belief in my own innovativeness by using computers and Knoblauch and Bannon's (I read their book in my second year of teaching and reread it a number of time) assertion of the philosophical and pedagogical superiority of epistemic beliefs, I saw myself as being better than some other teachers who might use other approaches (particularly formalist or current-traditional approaches). I was hypocritical, though, in this position.

I've come to see that these divisions and taxonomies are useful only to a point, and as I pointed out in my critique of Berlin, potentially damaging. I think it is truer to point out the ways in which these categories blend and mix that how they are different. I'll give one example: Let's say in my 1302 class I am having them write a researched argument on a contemporary issue (that you might find discussed in the show Justice Talking). We do a lot of drafting and peer response. We could say this is "expressivist" to an extent because the writer is searching for their "internal apprehension of truth" that is true for them--they are expressing their opinion. We do all this sharing of text and peer response, so it is epistemic in that their opinion is also socially negotiated and situated. Yet they are writing the essay as an academic argument/persuasion paper--a "critical essay" (see the link for my blueprint of this classic composition form). This essay form is very formalist and even current-traditional. But this doesn't follow the product-centered focus of c-t because we have developed this essay through a three draft process (which included invention activities and reflections). We might even add that a large challenge of the writer is the classical one of presenting their argument in a rhetorical way with a keen sense that they are not presenting absolute truths but approximations of truth within an uncertain situation. So we see how within this one assignment all four of Berlin's categories are mixed.

This same modal mixture can also happen between assignments. For instance, I typically have done my first assignment in English 1301 as a narrative (Ponsot and Dean's "Family Story"). Yet I follow that essay with the "Illustrative Essay" where they express a "truth" and illustrate it with stories. This second essay is highly rhetorical since I ask them to address an audience with a specific purpose in mind and I also ask them to use "essay form" (very formalist). All the while, I'm using what might be considered more expressivist approaches to the writing process with lots of drafting and peer response (I happen to be with Harris in saying the strict association of process pedagogy with expressivist practices is bunk).

So how useful are these categories afterall? Or better, how useful is it for us to attempt to be "pure" in our practice following one or the other of these models? Are these categories and dichotomies afterall more harmful than they are helpful--as Kay Halasek and Sherry Gradin ask?

These are some of the issues I dealt with in a paper I wrote last Fall ("Open Spaces: A Heuristic Toward a New Composition") and without belabouring the point I tend to agree with Halasek's alternative "architechtonics" of composition as performance and dialogue that occillates between what she calls "productivity" and "proficiency." I can't say, though, that my practice has reached this "New Composition" yet.




Bart Rules!

A video produced by my youngest son.

Sunday, June 17, 2007

Systems Approaches to Composition


Composition and Technology
As I think about Anson's article (and its connection to Lanham's "Audit of Virtuality"), Kearcher's article, and TOPIC (as an example of a systems approach to teaching composition), I see a key tension and dynamic at play. What does "systems" mean? How does the "system" work? I think one way we can answer these questions is to frame the "system" along these continuums:

Strategic---><---Tactic Closed---><---Open Anson closes his article warning of "those uses of technology that will lead to bad teaching, poor learning, unfair curricular practices, and unjust employment" (816). These warnings are the dark side of what systems approaches to composition could become. Let me start with the first pair: strategic-tactic. I'm taking the terms from Kearcher who uses them from Certeau, so I can't claim I fully understand them. I interpret Kearcher's use of the terms to revolve around issues of freedom and access. "Strategic" would describe the school's or teacher's predetermine elements of learning content and writing assignments--what she calls "institutionally-based writing instruction." We might question at what level the "institution" controls this instruction, and see a continuum from my department where we have a sketch of a common syllabus (with common learning outcomes and general course requirements) and teachers have complete freedom to teach what and how they like within that sketch to the scripted curriculum a friend of mine must follow in her Sophmore high school class at Smithson Valley High School (all teachers must be doing and saying the same things on the same day). What we see in a program like TOPIC is that the programmatic homogenenization of curriculum is facilitated via technology that runs through a central database. Depending upon the context, this systemization of a program might be for the good, but of central concern would be the level of agency that teachers have within that system. "Tactic" as Kearcher uses instead seems to focus on the student and seems to refer to access--the freedom to get to needed resources to meet individual needs at kairotic moments. I am totally excited about the possibilities for technology to serve as a "mediator" for action and learning in the way Kearcher describes, especially the way she describes access to a learning community (or rhetorical forum) to share writing. We might ask of systems approaches to composition if they could provide "tactical" help to teachers too. Rather than making the curriculum a monolith that restricts teachers (to say one syllabus and assignments and textbook), can it facilitate the "tactical" choices and actions teachers make as they teach as well? The second continuum we can frame systems approaches to composition upon is a similar one to the last and it is closed to open. I'm thinking particularly of how Clay Spinuzzi uses the terms at the end of his book on Genre Tracing. Computer "systems" have a tendency to "formalize" behavior--to push it through specific actions and behaviors. They are closed systems in that the users are not able to change the system in any way. In the teaching of writing, you don't have to have computers to get this level of formalization (as witnessed by my friend teaching from a scripted curriculum). The ideal, somehow, is to have a composition system that is open and adaptable for the teacher (user). The tensions in this dynamic of closed-open are enormous, but potentially powerful since it might combine the best of teachers interacting to find common ground (the need for some level of formalization and conformity amongst the curriculum) and teachers seeking ways to teach how they want and how they believe is best (from their own practical wisdom). IF the computer interface could facilitate this kind of open system, then I think we might have arrived.

Saturday, June 9, 2007

6/8 Post--Beliefs

Topic: What are the three most important concepts in composition would you say? These concepts might play a role in your teaching philosophy, so you might think of this question as what are the three most important beliefs about your own teaching do you have?

I've been walking around with this topic for almost a week thinking of what I would write. These two questions are actually two sides of the same coins--concept/practice or theory/practice. I've taught so long that most of my beliefs and practices are ingrained, and I have to stop and think to make them explicit. Here they are:

1) I believe in portfolios which is another way of saying I believe in the writing process. I've never thought of or used portfolios in Freshman Composition as a means of evaluation. Instead, it is the course-structuring framework that guides the complete tenor of the class. We are writing a book. We will write a number of writing pieces and along the way everything we write is "in process" and could be revised a zillion times if we wanted to. At the end, we will pick our best writing, revise it again, and turn it in within a "book." What this structure to the class provides is built in mechanism for revision. We revise pieces when they are first written, but it is that last effort at collection and selection and revision where students do their most significant writing. It sure makes a bear for me at the end of the semester as I grade them, but the end results and the growth I see in students is worth it.

2) I believe in "shared discourse" which is another way of saying I believe in collaboration and that students learn from their peers. Post-process folks call it "communicative interaction." I set up my class so that practically every piece of writing is turned in to a shared space where we all can read it. Only journals are private. We do intensive peer response, but also we do writings where we learn and grow from reading what we have done (without the need to respond). In this way, I seek to set up a writing community (or a rhetorical forum) where students gain a deeper sense of audience.

3) I believe students have an innate capacity with language and that their writing development improves with practice and takes time. What this means is that I affirm each of my students ability to communicate--they already have a complex capacity for linguistic expression. What I have to work on is helping students become more comfortable and "fluent" in written expression. So often their expression done through writing is stunted and strained, and I seek to open them up to expressing themselves in writing--the grammar and correctness will come in time. Freewriting is a very powerful tool in helping students gain comfort and confidence with writing, and each semester I hear students comment on how much they like it.

Those are my big three: portfolios, shared text, and expression. There is so much more to teaching composition, but these three are pretty good core beliefs and practices to my teaching. You are welcome to wander around my Freshman Composition site.

About Writing

Writing is always more precise and less precise than our thoughts: that is why our writing pieces glow with being and beckon with the promis...